Active IQ
Active IQ
Active IQ
Health Club Management

Health Club Management

Follow Health Club Management on Twitter Like Health Club Management on Facebook Join the discussion with Health Club Management on LinkedIn Subscribe to Health Club Management
Get the latest news, jobs and features in your inbox
Health Club Management

Health Club Management


Talking point: Gender specific training

Should we be offering gender-specific training?

By Kath Hudson | Published in Health Club Management 2018 issue 11

Many women believe cardio is the best way to burn fat, while many men favour doing more upper body training. Are these just preferences, mindsets and habits or are men and women actually pre-disposed to train differently?

To help members get the best results, should health and fitness operators be offering gender specific training, or is a shake-up and some re-education in order?

As more operators, such as Pure Gym and Total Fitness, offer women-only training areas, will we start to see more concepts aimed specifically at women? Could that help to grow the sector? Kath Hudson reports.

Jonny Taylor
Ultimate Performance: Deputy Global Head of Education and Development

How long a member has been training for has a bigger impact on programme design than gender PHOTO: SHUTTERSTOCK.COM

Jonny Taylor

Men and women don’t need to train differently, but we tend to find they want to. For a start, they have different aesthetic ideals: we find our female clients typically want to focus on posterior muscles (back, glutes and hamstrings), while our male clients emphasise the upper body (chest, back and arms). Societal/cultural factors also play a part. Until recently, females have tended to avoid lifting weights, stuck to group classes, or followed ineffective programmes for fear of becoming bulky.

How long you’ve trained for has a much bigger impact on programme design than gender, and all beginners need to develop the same general skill base. There are no major physiological differences in muscle quality between men and women and they adapt in the same way to resistance training. However, there is a difference in muscle quantity, with men tending to have bigger frames and more muscle mass, which makes them stronger in the gym.

The programmes we use for men and women, especially beginner clients, are very similar. Roughly 70 per cent of the workout is devoted to learning the main movement patterns, such as squatting, pressing and pulling and skills, including how to lift weights with control. This equates to two upper body exercises – one each for the front and back – such as dumbbell press and cable pull-down. Likewise for the lower body, for example, split squat and leg curl. These exercises are essential to a client’s long-term development, building a base of skills which allows them to specialise later.

The remaining 30 per cent of the programme is for addressing individual target areas, training the body parts that will benefit their physique the most. Often this does show a gender bias towards lower body and abs for females and chest and arms for males.

“Men and women have different aesthetic ideals: we find female clients want to focus on posterior muscles, while male clients emphasise the upper body”
Menno Henselmans
Bayesian Bodybuilding: owner

Group training classes can be a good way to offer strength training options to female members PHOTO: SHUTTERSTOCK.COM

Menno Henselmans

Many women believe that the key to their dream physique is cardio and burning lots of calories, but what they really need to do in order to change their physique is body recomposition: lose fat but gain muscle.

Health clubs don’t need to offer completely different programmes for men and women.

Most clients, whether they know it or not, should probably do a form of resistance training, as this is ideal for body recomposition. Strength training is ideal for muscle growth, and scientific research shows it’s generally more time-efficient than cardio for fat loss.

Cardio burns more calories acutely, but strength training stimulates muscle protein synthesis and excess post-exercise oxygen consumption: the metabolic afterburn. More muscle mass also increases metabolic rate. Strength training also more effectively suppresses appetite, and therefore energy intake.

As a result, over the long-run, strength training typically helps people to not only build more muscle, but also to lose more fat and end up with a more favourable body composition than is achieved if the same time is spent on cardio.

Group circuit training classes are a particularly good way for gyms to offer strength training for women. They have the social element to motivate and bind people together, while providing the best of resistance training and cardio, as well as strength training.

They also enable people to exercise at a high heart rate, creating enough fatigue to satisfy people’s need to feel they’ve had a good workout.

“Group circuit training is a good way for gyms to offer strength training for women. They create enough fatigue to satisfy people’s need to feel they’ve had a good workout”
Yasmin Hurkardes
Go30: Business Director
Yasmin Hurkardes

Women don’t necessarily need different training programmes from men, but many of them benefit from, and feel more comfortable with, training in a female-only environment.

Go30 runs two Essex-based ladies-only gyms, and we’ve found that both of these clubs have a real community feel and sense of sisterhood.

The vibe at a female-only gym is very different to a mixed club. There’s no gymtimidation factor and many feel much more confident without males present.

At one club, the membership is made up almost exclusively of women in their 60s, 70s and 80s, who tell us that they wouldn’t feel comfortable in a mixed environment and so wouldn’t go to the gym if we weren’t available. A large group of women who met at the gym now even go on holiday together.

Some people may think it’s sexist to not include men, but we believe we’re opening up the gym experience to a different market: hard to reach groups, such as older women and those who – because of religious beliefs – can’t train in a mixed health club environment.

Having a club that is open to everyone is a great concept as well, but our target market feel more comfortable exercising without men present. Going forward, I think we’ll see more boutique concepts aimed specifically at different markets, including more women-only gyms.

“Some people may think it’s sexist to not include men, but we believe we’re opening up the gym experience to a different market”
Alan Milway
MX Fitness: Founder and Coach to Elite Athletes

Some women can squat and deadlift as much as men per kilogram of body weight, but upper body training differs PHOTO: SHUTTERSTOCK.COM

Alan Milway

Initially, training should be specific to the individual, not gender. Poor posture or poor movement patterns aren’t gender specific. However, as training progresses, there are areas in strength and power development that can differ between males and females.

I’ve coached a number of females who can squat/deadlift very good figures per kilogram of bodyweight and get close to male figures, but I haven’t been able to achieve the same in upper body performance. Therefore, I feel female athletes who can gain strength and power in the upper body can have a performance advantage over others during competition.

Other than this difference in upper body strength, I have found the needs of the athletes I’ve worked with have not tended to be gender specific.

However, women are able to work at a higher percentage of their maximum lifts than men, and if you don’t accommodate for this then you can get programming wrong – as from sets of five reps I’ve put the weight up slightly, only to find that one rep is too much.

I like to get all people moving well – so they can lunge, squat, hinge, push, pull and rotate well. Once they are able to do this, I can add load and build global strength, then specify to the discipline or the athlete’s needs.

Good general robustness is better than big peaks and troughs in performance in the sports I work within. Setting targets is important and I’ve worked with females who varied greatly, so I felt individual focus was more important than gender focus. Many men would be humbled by these strong and powerful female athletes!

“Women are able to work at a higher percentage of their maximum lifts than men. If you don’t accommodate for this, you can get programming wrong”
Should operators be offering training that’s tailored to each gender? We ask four experts...
Latest News
Les Mills International (LMI) has enlisted the help of Marvel superheroes as part of efforts ...
Latest News
Xponential Fitness founder Anthony Geisler sees a dominant future for his boutique fitness business, and ...
Latest News
Double Olympic champion Max Whitlock has teamed up with leisure operator Everyone Active and awarding ...
Latest News
Private equity firm TSG Consumer Partners (TSG) has acquired CorePower Yoga from L Catterton for ...
Latest News
Enjoyment is the single biggest factor in motivating children to be active – while "physically ...
Latest News
Spartan, the obstacle course and endurance brand, has launched into the corporate wellness market with ...
Latest News
With the availability of qualified swimming teachers an issue nationally, leisure management trust Stevenage Leisure ...
Latest News
Drinking a protein shake just before going to bed at night might increase gains in ...
Latest News
A new study has found that taking part in structured exercise such as team sports ...
Latest News
The Gym Group has tackled investor chatter about stagnation in market penetration by collaborating with ...
Latest News
Corporate fitness sales specialist Gympass has secured a partnership deal with IWG, one of the ...
Job search
Featured supplier news
Featured supplier: Barcelona Bootcamp to launch corporate preferred rates for company retreats
Apart from the incredible scenery, delicious meals, and beautiful locations, there is another reason to choose Barcelona Bootcamp for your next company retreat.
Featured supplier news
Featured supplier: Dyaco UK launches the Johnny G Spirit Bike with first installation at Feelgood Fitness, Grantham
Dyaco UK has announced the official launch of the long-awaited Johnny G Spirit Bike to the UK, with the first installation in Feelgood Fitness in Grantham
Company profiles
Company profile: Matrix Fitness
At Matrix Fitness, our goal is to make innovative commercial fitness equipment that stands out ...
Company profiles
Company profile: Power Plate
Power Plate is a vibrating platform that enhances any movement to help you prepare faster, ...
Catalogue Gallery
Click on a catalogue to view it online
Member access schemes
Move GB: Member access schemes
Hydrotherapy / spa fragrances
Kemitron GmbH: Hydrotherapy / spa fragrances
Total Vibration Solutions Ltd: Flooring
Direct debit solutions
Debit Finance Collections: Direct debit solutions
Corporate retreats
Barcelona Bootcamp: Corporate retreats
Locking solutions
Ojmar: Locking solutions
Zynk Design Consultants: Architects/designers
Fitness equipment
FunXtion International BV: Fitness equipment
Management software
GymSales: Management software
Audio visual
Hutchison Technologies: Audio visual
Property & Tenders
Kirklees Active Leisure
Property & Tenders
New Brighton, Wirral, Merseyside
Wirral Borough Council
Property & Tenders
Diary dates
27-28 Mar 2019
Eastwood Hall, Nottingham, United Kingdom
Diary dates
24-25 Apr 2019
Business Design Centre, London, United Kingdom
Diary dates
Active IQ
Active IQ